Methodology
How the Daycare Confidence Index Is Calculated
A 0 to 100 score built only from what can be verified about a provider. Regulatory and safety history, parent reviews and profile transparency make up the score, and accreditation adds a bonus. A fifth area, staff qualifications, is not scored for any provider yet. Which areas count for a provider depends on what the public record holds for it. The score exists to help families compare providers quickly. It never replaces a visit, your own questions, or your own judgment.
How the categories add up
Four areas share a provider's score. The shares below are the most each can be worth, in the case where all four can be checked. A fifth, accreditation, is a bonus on top of the score, worth up to 12.5 points. A provider without accreditation is never marked down for it.
That case is rare. When a category cannot be checked for a provider, it is removed from that provider's calculation entirely, from the total and from the divisor both, and the remaining categories are re-weighted against each other. One is unavailable for every provider today: staff qualifications, which Florida's records do not publish per provider in a form we can read.
Regulatory history carries the largest ceiling because it is the one input verified independently by a government inspector. Profile transparency carries the smallest.
These shares are ceilings, not the formula. A category we cannot check for a provider drops out of that provider's score entirely, and the remaining categories are re-weighted against each other. Accreditation is not a share. It adds a bonus on top, so not having one never lowers a score.
- Regulatory & Safetyup to 57% of a scoreSafety history from Florida's own inspection records.
- Parent Reviewsup to 19% of a scoreLived experience of families, adjusted so a handful of reviews cannot skew the picture.
- Accreditationa bonus of up to 12.5 pointsInvestment in quality beyond basic licensing.
- Staff Qualificationsup to 14% of a scoreNot scored yetNot yet scoreable. Florida's records do not publish this per provider.
- Transparencyup to 10% of a scoreHow much practical information a provider actually shares.
What each category measures
Regulatory & Safety (up to 57% of a score)
Florida's inspection reports drive this category. Each inspection is graded on its own, out of 100. Each finding takes a share off the inspection where it was found, and the share depends on its class. Class 1, an imminent threat to child safety, takes the most. Class 3, usually paperwork or procedure, takes the least. A problem found again at the next inspection counts extra. The inspections are then averaged, with recent ones counting more and none older than five years. Each Class 1 finding also costs a further fixed amount that fades over five years. The steps and a worked example are below. Enforcement actions such as warnings, corrective action, probation, suspension, emergency closure, or license revocation would also lower this category, and a recent revocation caps it at 30 while a recent emergency closure caps it at 40. Florida's enforcement actions are not yet in a form our pipeline reads, so nothing on the site has been scored against them. A provider with no inspection in the last five years, such as a new or license-exempt program, has this category left out of its score. It is not scored as a clean record or as a failing one, and the provider needs at least five parent reviews to be scored at all.
Parent Reviews (up to 19% of a score)
The provider's Google rating, or its Yelp rating when Google has none, and how many reviews stand behind it. A statistical adjustment pulls a small number of reviews toward a typical rating, so a handful of reviews cannot swing the score far. A larger review count earns a bonus, and so does a recent review. A wide spread across Google's 1 to 5 star breakdown takes points off. Reviews can earn at most 20 points, against 60 for the inspection record, before the total is scaled to 0 to 100.
Accreditation (a bonus of up to 12.5 points)
Recognized national accreditations such as NAEYC, the National Accreditation Commission, and APPLE. Accreditation is a bonus added on top of the score, worth up to 12.5 points out of 100. Having accreditation raises the score. Not having it never lowers it, because it is not part of what the other categories are measured against. Many strong providers have simply not pursued accreditation yet.
Staff Qualifications (up to 14% of a score)
Not scored yetA recognized director credential, CDA-qualified staff, staff with bachelor's degrees in Early Childhood Education, and high completion rates for required staff training. Florida's records do not publish per-provider staff credentials in a form our pipeline can read, so this category is excluded from every provider's score today and its share of the total is currently zero. It is listed here because the design is built and waiting on a source, not because it is quietly counting against anyone. Lack of documented qualifications has never implied poor quality.
Transparency (up to 10% of a score)
Operating hours, phone number, website, photos, curriculum information, meals information, participation in Florida's Voluntary Prekindergarten (VPK) and School Readiness programs, and special needs or accessibility details. Each of these nine items a profile lists adds one point. The category is out of 10. The tenth point is for fee information, which we do not read from any source yet, so no provider earns it today.
How we label the overall score
Every provider's overall score maps to one of four labels so it stays easy to interpret at a glance:
- 90+High Confidence
- 75+Solid Option
- 60+Mixed Signals – Review Carefully
- 0+Elevated Risk – Review Carefully
Every score comes with a range
Two providers can share the same score with very different evidence behind it: one backed by years of inspections and hundreds of reviews, the other by a handful of reviews and nothing else. So alongside each score we compute a statistical range (a Wilson interval) that narrows as verified evidence accumulates. Thin evidence means a wide range. Rich evidence means a tight one.
A provider shows one score everywhere: on its profile, in city lists and in every ranking. The profile also prints the range under the score, so you can see how much evidence stands behind it. A wide range is a reason to ask more questions, not a lower score.
Missing data is left out, not guessed at
This is the rule behind the coverage section above, stated once more because it is the one most easily misread. When a category cannot be checked, it drops out of the calculation rather than scoring zero, and the remaining categories are re-weighted so the provider is judged only on what can actually be verified.
It does not score as full marks either. A category with nothing to read is neither a spotless record nor a failing one. And when a violation is on file but its severity is not, we score it at the moderate middle weight and disclose the count, rather than guessing at the worst or quietly ignoring it.
Why some providers show no score at all
A score needs something real behind it: an inspection in the last five years or at least five parent reviews. Without either, a number computed from a statistical prior and a few profile fields would read as a judgment of the provider when it is only a judgment of our data, so we publish none. Most Florida providers here have inspections on file, but a new or license-exempt program may have none yet. A Florida profile that says “Not scored” has neither, or has no score on file yet.
Why a high score can be missing from a ranked list
The ranked lists built on the inspection record, the index rankings and the Safest lists, leave out a provider cited at inspection three or more years in a row, counting back from this year or last year. The score averages every visit, so clean visits between findings can keep it high. A record with findings year after year says more than that average does. The provider keeps its score and its profile, and its full inspection record is on that profile.
Why we always show the category breakdown
One opaque number would hide the story. Every profile shows the score for each category so you can see where a provider is strong and where you might want to ask a follow-up question. A provider with a strong regulatory history and no accreditation is a different story than a provider with mixed inspections and pristine reviews, and only you can weigh which story matters most for your family.
Legal disclaimer
The Daycare Confidence Index and related ratings are provided for general informational purposes only. The Index is generated from third-party data sources, including public licensing and enforcement records and user reviews, which may be incomplete, updated on different schedules, or contain errors. We do not independently verify all information used in the Index, and we do not endorse, certify, or guarantee any childcare provider. The Index does not constitute professional advice or a determination of a provider's safety, compliance, or fitness for your child. Ratings are subject to change as new information becomes available and may not reflect the most recent events at a provider. By using this site, you agree that you are solely responsible for your childcare decisions and that you will conduct your own due diligence, including visiting providers in person, reviewing official state records, and consulting qualified professionals as needed. We are not liable for any decisions you make based on the Daycare Confidence Index or information displayed on this site.
Questions or corrections? Contact us.